GREATThinner and lower quality than the citizen loops they replaced, also just a bit too large despite being ordered for the correct size.Wrong size too bigThese seem a little softer and thinner than the original loops on my Fossil watch thus a 4 rating but they work just fine. Only time will tell. For what they are, they could be considered a little pricey but it is certainly better than having to purchase a new band. So try them.Husband purchased a watchband two months ago and the loop already broke. Could not see purchasing another band so we bought a package of these to use. He said it fits perfectly and we have extras if we need them. They look sturdy.Used one of these on my Mudmaster. Very happy with it. Now my strap stays in place all day long, no extra bowed out area. very pleased.Great replacement for my watch bands straps.This didn’t fit my watch and I’m really sad :(